David Crisafulli, the newly elected Premier of Queensland, has outlined a 100-day plan that includes significant measures to address youth crime.
The key elements of Crisafulli’s youth crime plan include:
- Drafting and passing the “Making Queensland Safer” bill by the end of the year.
- Implementing an “adult crime, adult time” approach, which suggests harsher penalties for young offenders.
- Beginning tenders for the Regional Reset program to divert youth from crime.
- Initiating tenders for the Staying on Track program to rehabilitate youth offenders.
- Meeting with the Police Commissioner to outline additional support needed to address the youth crime crisis.
Crisafulli has emphasised the urgency of addressing youth crime. However, experts are sceptical about the effectiveness of this approach for several reasons:
- The 100-day timeframe is considered too short to implement meaningful, long-term solutions to complex social issues like youth crime.
- The “adult crime, adult time” policy has been criticized by criminologists and social workers as potentially counterproductive, as it may not address the root causes of youth crime.
- Experts argue that more emphasis should be placed on early intervention and prevention strategies rather than punitive measures.
- Given that Indigenous youth are overrepresented in the criminal justice system, there are concerns that harsher penalties could disproportionately affect these communities.
- Harsher penalties for young offenders might lead to increased recidivism rates and further entrenchment in the criminal justice system.
While Crisafulli’s plan demonstrates a strong commitment to addressing youth crime, experts suggest that a more comprehensive, long-term strategy that balances prevention, rehabilitation, and community support may be more effective in achieving lasting reductions in youth crime rates.
Currently, the Youth Justice Act 1992 in Queensland establishes a comprehensive framework for dealing with young offenders, aiming to balance community safety with rehabilitation and reintegration of youth. The key principles and purposes of the Act include:
- Establishing a fair and balanced youth justice system that holds young offenders accountable while recognising their unique needs and vulnerabilities.
- Prioritising community safety, particularly from serious repeat offenders.
- Encouraging young offenders to accept responsibility for their actions and make amends.
- Recognising the importance of family and community, especially Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, in rehabilitating and reintegrating young offenders.
- Ensuring that detention is used only as a last resort and for the shortest appropriate period.
- Encouraging parental involvement and responsibility in addressing youth offending and allowing victim participation in the justice process.
- Promoting reintegration into the community through education, training, and employment opportunities.
The Act provides a range of sentencing options, including restorative justice orders, probation, community service, and detention, to address different levels of offending. It also emphasises the importance of rehabilitation programs and support services to address the underlying causes of youth crime and reduce reoffending.
Our team are experts in criminal law, including Youth Justice. Our role is to sit down with you and work out the strategy that will get you the best possible result.
If you have any questions about this article or any other topic of law, please call our team of experts on 1300 066 669.
