Brooke Winter Solicitors acted for a client at trial in the Southport District Court in September 2025. The jury found him not guilty of rape but guilty of choking with intent to facilitate the commission of an indictable offence.

Brooke Winter Solicitors and Counsel successfully argued for bail pending sentence and immediately lodged an appeal against the conviction. The client subsequently received a suspended sentence, with no time to serve.

Mr Baskerville-Hodge instructed Greg Barns SC and Ambyr Cousen in the appeal, arguing that the verdicts were inconsistent.

Following written submissions and a hearing, the Court of Appeal agreed that, given the way the prosecution had confined its case, the rape acquittal could not be reconciled with the choking conviction.

In November 2026, the Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction and ordered that a verdict of not guilty be entered.

Having guided the client through trial, sentence and appeal, Mr Baskerville-Hodge and the team at Brooke Winter Solicitors achieved an outstanding result, preserving the client’s clear criminal history.